Home / RBT Study Guide / Behavior Reduction / Differential reinforcement: DRA, DRI, DRO, DRL and FCT
Domain D · Behavior Reduction · Task D.3
Differential reinforcement: DRA, DRI, DRO, DRL and FCT
Differential reinforcement means reinforcing one response and withholding reinforcement for another. DRA, DRI, DRO and DRL differ only in what earns the reinforcer.
Last reviewed November 10, 2026 against the BACB RBT Test Content Outline (3rd ed.)
What differential reinforcement means
Differential reinforcement has two parts that always go together: you reinforce one response, and you withhold reinforcement for another. Over time the reinforced response grows and the other one fades.
Task D.3 in the outline lists five procedures as examples: DRO, DRA, DRI, DRL and FCT. They all follow the same logic. What changes from one to the next is the rule for what earns the reinforcer. Your supervisor chooses the procedure, the reinforcer and the schedule. You deliver the reinforcer exactly when the rule is met, and not when it is not.
These procedures work best when the reinforcer matches the function of the behavior. If calling out is maintained by attention, the replacement behavior should earn attention.
DRA, DRI, DRO, DRL and FCT at a glance
| Procedure | Stands for | What earns reinforcement | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| DRA | Differential reinforcement of alternative behavior | A specific appropriate behavior that replaces the problem behavior | Raising a hand earns the teacher's attention, and calling out does not |
| DRI | Differential reinforcement of incompatible behavior | A specific behavior that cannot happen at the same time as the problem behavior | Sitting in the chair is reinforced, to replace wandering the room |
| DRO | Differential reinforcement of other behavior | The absence of the problem behavior for a set time | A token for every 5 minutes with no hitting |
| DRL | Differential reinforcement of low rates | The behavior itself, when it happens at or below a set limit | A reward when "Is it time yet?" is asked 3 times or fewer in a lesson |
| FCT | Functional communication training | A communication response that gets the same reinforcer the problem behavior got | Handing over a "break" card earns a break, and throwing materials does not |
FCT is a special kind of DRA. The alternative behavior is a way of communicating (a word, a sign, a picture card, a device button), and it produces exactly what the problem behavior used to produce.
How to tell them apart
Ask these questions in order.
- Is a specific replacement behavior named? If no, and reinforcement depends on the problem behavior being absent for a period of time, it is DRO.
- Is the target behavior itself still allowed, just less often? If reinforcement is given for keeping it under a limit, it is DRL.
- Could the replacement and the problem behavior happen at the same moment? If they could, it is DRA. If they physically could not, it is DRI.
- Is the replacement a request for the same reinforcer? Then the DRA is functional communication training.
Common mix-up
DRA vs DRI: every DRI is a DRA with one extra feature, incompatibility. A child can raise a hand and call out at once, so hand raising is an alternative (DRA). A child cannot be seated and running around at once, so sitting is incompatible (DRI). When both appear as answer choices, pick DRI only if the scenario makes the two behaviors impossible to do together.
DRO stands apart from the rest because it reinforces a period of time without the behavior, not a particular response. That is also its weakness: it does not teach the learner what to do instead. DRO also gets confused with noncontingent reinforcement, which runs on a timer too. In NCR the reinforcer comes regardless of behavior. In DRO it comes only if the behavior did not occur. NCR is covered under antecedent interventions.
Worked scenarios
In session
DRA. Mia grabs toys from peers. Her plan teaches her to hold out her hand and say "my turn". When she does, she gets the toy for two minutes. When she grabs, the toy goes back to the peer.
In session
DRO. Sam bites his hand during table work. His plan sets a 2-minute timer. If the timer ends with no biting, he gets a token. The plan also says what to do with the timer if biting occurs, and you follow that rule each time.
In session
DRL. Priya asks "Did I do it right?" about 30 times in a work period. Asking is fine, but that rate keeps her from working. Her plan gives her five "question tickets". If she has used five or fewer by the end, she earns computer time. The limit is lowered later by the supervisor.
In session
FCT. Diego throws his worksheet, which used to end the task. Now you prompt him to hand you a "break" card. He gets a one-minute break right away. Throwing no longer ends the task.
In each scenario the problem behavior stops paying off while something else starts to. That withholding half is extinction, and it is why differential reinforcement and extinction are usually written into a plan together.
Your role when running differential reinforcement
- Be quick. Reinforce the target response immediately, especially early on. A new replacement behavior often starts on a rich schedule, and the supervisor thins it later. See schedules of reinforcement.
- Be consistent. If the problem behavior still pays off some of the time, the learner has no reason to switch.
- Keep the timer honest. In DRO and DRL the interval and the limit are exact. Do not round them in the learner's favor.
- Record and report. Track both the problem behavior and the replacement. If the replacement is not increasing, tell your supervisor. Do not change the reinforcer or the interval yourself.
How the exam tests differential reinforcement
On the exam
A common question format gives a short scenario and four abbreviations. Find the sentence that states the rule for earning reinforcement and run the four questions above. Words like "no instances for 5 minutes" signal DRO. "Fewer than" or "no more than" signals DRL. A named replacement signals DRA or DRI. A request that gets the same thing signals FCT. The Behavior Reduction overview places these alongside the other domain D tasks.
Practice questions
Original questions in the style of the exam. Pick an answer before you open the explanation.
1. Sam earns a sticker each time 10 minutes pass with no biting. His plan does not name any particular behavior he has to do in that time. Which procedure is this?
- DRA
- DRI
- DRO
- DRL
Show answer
C. DRO
Reinforcement depends only on the problem behavior being absent for a set interval, which defines DRO. DRA is the closest distractor, but it would name a specific alternative behavior that earns the sticker.
2. Leo sometimes hits peers in the hallway. His plan reinforces walking with both hands in his pockets. What makes this DRI and not simply DRA?
- The two behaviors cannot occur together
- The two behaviors serve the same function
- The behavior is absent for a set interval
- The behavior stays under a set rate limit
Show answer
A. The two behaviors cannot occur together
DRI reinforces a behavior that is physically incompatible with the problem behavior: Leo cannot hit while his hands are in his pockets. A plain DRA replacement can occur alongside the problem behavior, such as raising a hand while also calling out.
3. Diego throws his worksheet to get out of work. His plan teaches him to hand over a break card, which earns a short break, while throwing no longer ends the task. How is this best described?
- DRO with extinction
- FCT, a form of DRA
- DRL with extinction
- NCR with extinction
Show answer
B. FCT, a form of DRA
Diego is taught a communication response that produces the same reinforcer (escape) the problem behavior used to produce, which is functional communication training, a type of DRA. DRO would reinforce time without throwing and would not teach him a way to ask.
Common questions
What is the difference between DRA and DRI?
Both reinforce a specific replacement behavior. In DRI the replacement is physically incompatible with the problem behavior, so the two cannot happen at the same moment, like sitting and running. In DRA the replacement is appropriate but could occur alongside the problem behavior.
What does DRO stand for and how does it work?
DRO stands for differential reinforcement of other behavior. The learner earns reinforcement when the problem behavior has not occurred for a set amount of time. No particular replacement behavior is required, which is how you tell DRO apart from DRA and DRI.
Is DRL used to eliminate a behavior?
No. Differential reinforcement of low rates is used to reduce a behavior that is acceptable in itself but happens too often, such as asking for help or raising a hand. The learner is reinforced for keeping the behavior at or below a set limit, not for stopping it.